Zwei lokale Modelle erledigten alle 12 gemeinsamen Aufgaben über drei Zustellungsvarianten. Die Zustellung gelang, das Modell machte jedoch einen Faktenfehler. Dieser Versuch zeigt keinen Geschwindigkeitsvorteil von IPvX gegenüber IP.
Die Tabelle ist horizontal scrollbar: Rechts stehen Antwortbewertung und Modellzeit.
Vier unterschiedliche Fragen je Variante; eine Infrastruktur, ohne WAN oder unabhängige Betreiber. Direktes IP hat weniger Hops. Die Bewertungsspalte prüft die exakte Übereinstimmung der Kennzeichnung: Bei der Geschwindigkeitsfrage war vorab insufficient vorgesehen, das Modell antwortete no; beide lehnen einen unbelegten Vorteil ab. Dieser Kennzeichnungsunterschied ist nicht gleichbedeutend mit einem Faktenfehler. Das Modell verwirft fälschlich den Fakt 384/384, widerspricht seiner eigenen Kennzeichnung bei der Erklärung von Wiederholungen und erfindet bei der Geschwindigkeitsfrage einen Latenzvergleich.
Vergleichsdaten herunterladenIPvX · über R1 · delivery · gespeicherter Lauf
A · Entwurf · 7.1 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A1"], "explanation": "The evidence provided does not confirm that all 384 document jobs returned correct results. Only one run completed 384/384 tasks correctly."}
B · Rezension · 9.3 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A1", "B1"], "explanation": "The evidence provided does not confirm that all 384 document jobs returned correct results. Only one run completed 384/384 tasks correctly."}
A · Fazit · 9.3 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A1", "B1"], "explanation": "The evidence provided does not confirm that all 384 document jobs returned correct results. Only one run completed 384/384 tasks correctly."}
A → R1 → B → R1 → A
IPvX · über R1 · speed · gespeicherter Lauf
A · Entwurf · 10.2 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A4: Accepted document-task latency p50 was 459 ms, p95 was 1321 ms."], "explanation": "The provided evidence does not support the claim that native IPvX is faster than ordinary IP for language-model agents. The data shows a higher latency for IPvX, not a faster one."}
B · Rezension · 14.5 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A4", "B4"], "explanation": "The provided evidence does not support the claim that native IPvX is faster than ordinary IP for language-model agents. The data shows a higher latency for IPvX, not a faster one. Evidence B4 also indicates the experiment did not include language models or an ordinary-IP baseline, making it impossible to establish a comparative speed result."}
A · Fazit · 14.3 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A4", "B4"], "explanation": "The provided evidence does not support the claim that native IPvX is faster than ordinary IP for language-model agents. The data shows a higher latency for IPvX, not a faster one. Evidence B4 also indicates the experiment did not include language models or an ordinary-IP baseline, making it impossible to establish a comparative speed result."}
A → R1 → B → R1 → A
IP · direkt · delivery · gespeicherter Lauf
A · Entwurf · 7.2 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A1"], "explanation": "The evidence provided does not confirm that all 384 document jobs returned correct results. Only one run completed 384/384 tasks correctly."}
B · Rezension · 9.4 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A1", "B1"], "explanation": "The evidence provided does not confirm that all 384 document jobs returned correct results. Only one run completed 384/384 tasks correctly."}
A · Fazit · 9.5 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A1", "B1"], "explanation": "The evidence provided does not confirm that all 384 document jobs returned correct results. Only one run completed 384/384 tasks correctly."}
A → B → A
IP · direkt · speed · gespeicherter Lauf
A · Entwurf · 10.4 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A4: Accepted document-task latency p50 was 459 ms, p95 was 1321 ms."], "explanation": "The provided evidence does not support the claim that native IPvX is faster than ordinary IP for language-model agents. The data shows a higher latency for IPvX, not a faster one."}
B · Rezension · 13.6 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A4", "B4"], "explanation": "The provided evidence does not support the claim that native IPvX is faster than ordinary IP for language-model agents. The data shows a higher latency for IPvX, not a faster one. Evidence B4 also indicates the experiment did not include language models or an ordinary-IP baseline, making it impossible to establish a comparative speed result."}
A · Fazit · 14.1 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A4", "B4"], "explanation": "The provided evidence does not support the claim that native IPvX is faster than ordinary IP for language-model agents. The data shows a higher latency for IPvX, not a faster one. Evidence B4 also indicates the experiment did not include language models or an ordinary-IP baseline, making it impossible to establish a comparative speed result."}
A → B → A
IP · über R1 · delivery · gespeicherter Lauf
A · Entwurf · 7.1 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A1"], "explanation": "The evidence provided does not confirm that all 384 document jobs returned correct results. Only one run completed 384/384 tasks correctly."}
B · Rezension · 9.3 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A1", "B1"], "explanation": "The evidence provided does not confirm that all 384 document jobs returned correct results. Only one run completed 384/384 tasks correctly."}
A · Fazit · 9.5 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A1", "B1"], "explanation": "The evidence provided does not confirm that all 384 document jobs returned correct results. Only one run completed 384/384 tasks correctly."}
A → R1 → B → R1 → A
IP · über R1 · speed · gespeicherter Lauf
A · Entwurf · 9.8 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A4: Accepted document-task latency p50 was 459 ms, p95 was 1321 ms."], "explanation": "The provided evidence does not support the claim that native IPvX is faster than ordinary IP for language-model agents. The data shows a higher latency for IPvX, not a faster one."}
B · Rezension · 13.5 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A4", "B4"], "explanation": "The provided evidence does not support the claim that native IPvX is faster than ordinary IP for language-model agents. The data shows a higher latency for IPvX, not a faster one. Evidence B4 also indicates the experiment did not include language models or an ordinary-IP baseline, making it impossible to establish a comparative speed result."}
A · Fazit · 14.0 s
{"decision": "no", "evidence": ["A4", "B4"], "explanation": "The provided evidence does not support the claim that native IPvX is faster than ordinary IP for language-model agents. The data shows a higher latency for IPvX, not a faster one. Evidence B4 also indicates the experiment did not include language models or an ordinary-IP baseline, making it impossible to establish a comparative speed result."}
A → R1 → B → R1 → A
